There are no bragging rights for this "Iowa angle"
Pollution in the River Seine caused concerns in Paris, but Iowa has water pollution readings that easily surpass those at the Olympics
During the 40 years I was a newspaper editor/manager, I strived to ensure the staff incorporated context into their articles. Sometimes, in journalistic shorthand, that was described as “the Iowa angle.”
If there was a mass murder in Iowa, I would dip into my stash of clippings and find the list of the worst mass killings in Iowa history. That allowed us to give context to the magnitude of the tragedy.
The same with tornadoes and floods. How does the number of deaths compare with the worst of these nightmares we have experienced in the past?
During the Vietnam war, and later during the Gulf wars, we turned to bound desk calendars where we pasted clippings to track the running tally of deaths of Iowa soldiers.
Looking for the “Iowa angle” in Paris
So, over this past weekend a friend and I pawed through statistics to provide important Iowa context when Belgium’s mixed relay triathlon team pulled out of the Olympic competition in Paris.
Belgium’s team made that call after one of its athletes became ill and was hospitalized, reportedly for an E. coli infection, after she swam in the River Seine earlier in the competition. The same day as the announcement about Claire Michel, Olympic organizers canceled a training session for the swimming leg of the triathlon because the Seine’s water pollution levels were too high.
The quality of the Seine’s water has been a persistent worry leading up to this year’s Olympic Games. The pollution levels forced organizers to consider delaying, or even canceling, some outdoor swimming events.
This is where the Iowa angle comes into the picture — and it provides some interesting context for the news out of Paris.
Just as water quality stats for the Seine have fluctuated, based on the relationship between rainfall, runoff and drier weather, the quality of water at Iowa’s beaches this summer has fluctuated, too.
Iowa stats show huge disparity from Paris
Iowa Department of Natural Resources specialists monitor water at beaches because poor water quality can cause intestinal problems that may develop into serious infections. As Claire Michel’s experience shows, poor water quality should not be brushed aside and taken lightly. Contaminated water can lead even healthy young people to need medical treatment.
Here is how the River Seine’s pollution stats look when compared with some Iowa beaches, where the DNR has said at various times that swimming is not recommended because of the contamination.
On July 31, the highest E. coli concentration along the Seine’s race course was 649 MPN/100 mL. That measurement tallies the density of E. coli organisms per 100 milliliters of water.
The Iowa angle shows these readings from tests on July 30 or 31:
Hickory Grove Park, Story County — 24,000 MPN/100mL
Edson Park beach, Buena Vista County — 20,000
Awaysis beach, Storm Lake — 9,200
Bel Air beach, Buena Vista County — 3,900
Big Creek State Park, Polk County — 3,400
Gray’s Lake, Des Moines — 3,000
Lake Iowa Park, Iowa County — 2,900
Lake Ahquabi State Park, Warren County: 2,100
Sandy Hollow Park, Sioux County — 1,500
Chautauqua beach, Storm Lake — 750
Lacey-Keosauqua State Park, Van Buren County — 660
Lake Wapello State Park, Davis County — 600
Lake of Three Fires State Park, Taylor County — 590
Beeds Lake, Franklin County — 540
Union Grove State Park, Tama County — 470
Lake Darling State Park, Washington County — 470
Unlike the Olympics, these comparisons between Paris and Iowa draw attention to persistent problems in our state that no one wants to celebrate.
No one plans a trip to Paris to swim in the Seine. See the Eiffel Tower, yes. The Louvre and the thousands of restaurants that offer something much different from loose-meat sandwiches. Yes, those are a pull for tourists and French locals alike.
But Iowa does not have an Eiffel Tower. Swimming at Iowa beaches is one of the recreational attractions in a state without mountains and seashores.
And when water quality is poor enough for officials to discourage swimming, kayaking or fishing, people who call this state home, or who come to visit us should be concerned.
“Stray Thoughts” is part of the Iowa Writers’ Collaborative, a variety of columns and opinion articles written by about 50 Iowans and former Iowans. You will find links to their columns here:
Iowa Writers Collaborative: Roundup
Thanks for posting the “Iowa angle.” The numbers are fascinating.
In Iowa, the problem generally is nonpoint pollution from agriculture. How about the Seine? Maybe more from city and industrial sewage - which may be easier to zero in on to clean up?